As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links in this article may be affiliate links. How we choose gear
A new beginner clarinet starts at about $500 and up, according to the Royal Conservatory of Music’s teacher buying guide, while one dealer page for a professional bass clarinet to low C shows a price in five figures. Same family of instrument, a price gap of more than twenty to one. That spread is why “which one should I buy?” has no single answer for the 2027 school year or for anyone coming back to the horn as an adult.
The findings below rest on maker spec pages, dealer listings, that conservatory guide and long-running woodwind forum threads, and wherever a point is a single player’s opinion, the text says so. Five picks follow, each tied to one kind of player: a first-year band student, someone ready for a wooden horn, a school bass clarinetist, a player who needs the full low register, and the bass player whose mouthpiece is holding the instrument back. Prices appear only as ranges, and where no page I could open gave one, you are pointed to the live Amazon.com listing instead.
What actually separates one clarinet from another
Three things do most of the sorting: what the body is made of, how low the instrument plays, and what you blow into.
Start with material. The Royal Conservatory’s guide says “Plastic or hard rubber clarinets are usually preferable for younger children and beginners,” and it adds that grenadilla wood is warmer but cracks in dry or cold conditions. Jazz Bari Sax, whose author works for Vandoren, makes a similar split: wood is generally considered better sounding, while plastic and hybrid bodies are cheaper to keep alive, and the tonal gap matters mostly to advanced players.
Range is the second dial, and it only matters on the bass. The same Jazz Bari Sax article explains that low C goes three notes lower than low Eb and that the extra notes add length, weight and keys. Backun’s fingering guide agrees on the keys: a low C model gains left-pinky, right-pinky and right-thumb keys, and low D exists only on low C instruments.
The mouthpiece is the third. A buying roundup at Hello Music Theory tells readers not to fret over the stock mouthpiece, since included ones are generally of lower quality, and Violet Recording describes the stock Yamaha 4C as adequate but basic. That is a cheap part to change later, which is worth remembering before paying extra for a bigger name on the body.
Clarinet best brands, sorted by the level each is known for
The conservatory guide names the same handful of makers at every level, which makes the pattern easy to see. Starter models: Buffet B12, Selmer Vito and Bundy, Yamaha 250, and Jupiter. Intermediate: Buffet E11, Selmer CL211, Leblanc Bliss and Yamaha 450, in a bracket the guide puts at roughly $1,000 to $2,000. Professional starts around $3,000 with the Buffet Festival, Selmer 10s and Yamaha 650, and climbs through the Buffet R13 and RC to the Buffet Tosca and Yamaha Custom 850.
Yamaha is the name that spans the whole ladder. Jazz Bari Sax calls its instruments sturdy and reliable from student to professional level, which is useful if you want a straight upgrade path without relearning a layout. The same article treats Buffet Crampon as the top-of-the-line professional name, with Selmer Paris as its main competitor.
One filter matters more than any brand ranking: whether a technician can get parts. The guide warns that many cheap overseas clarinets have poor keywork and that replacement parts for budget brands can be hard or impossible to find. A commenter under a JazzFuel brand roundup makes the same complaint about Jean Paul and Cecilio/Mendini, which suggests the problem is widely noticed, though the commenter’s claim is a single voice.
Where the five picks differ on material, range, and money
| Model | Level | Built from | Range or key spec | Price signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yamaha YCL-255 | Student Bb | Matte ABS resin | 17 keys, 6 rings, 65 mm barrel | Check the current price on Amazon.com |
| Buffet Crampon E11 | Step-up Bb | African blackwood (grenadilla) | 17 keys, 6 rings, undercut tone holes | Conservatory bracket for intermediate: about $1,000 to $2,000 |
| Selmer 1430LP | Student bass | One-piece Resonite ABS | Down to low Eb | Check the current price on Amazon.com |
| Yamaha YCL-622II | Professional bass | Grenadilla wood | 24 keys, down to low C | Around $12,000 to $13,000 at one dealer |
| Vandoren B45 Bass Clarinet Mouthpiece | Accessory | Not stated on the page | 1.93 mm tip, medium-long facing | Around $190 to $200 at a specialist dealer |
Two gaps jump out. The Yamaha YCL-622II costs more than twenty times what the conservatory guide quotes for a starter instrument, and it is the only model here that reaches low C. The Selmer 1430LP sits at the opposite end of the bass family: one piece of resin, a low Eb limit, and a body built to survive a band room.
Best clarinet for each player: five situations, five picks
Each entry starts from a player, then works back to the instrument.
1. Yamaha YCL-255 — a durable first horn for band
Marching fields, cold gym floors and a backpack in the bus rack are what a first clarinet gets used to, and that is the case for an ABS resin body rather than wood. Yamaha’s own spec page lists the Yamaha YCL-255 with a matte ABS resin body and barrel, a 65 mm barrel, 17 keys and 6 rings, nickel-plated nickel-silver keys, straight tone holes with a tapered undercut, a 4C mouthpiece, a case, and an adjustable thumb rest with a strap ring. A dealer page for the same model adds Valentino pads and stainless-steel springs. Yamaha also sells a silver-plated sibling, the YCL-255S, so check which key finish a listing describes.
Consider a hypothetical eleven-year-old with small hands and a band director who wants matched equipment. The adjustable thumb rest lets the instrument grow with the player, which a fixed rest cannot do.
Violet Recording’s beginner guide puts the model’s strengths at consistent intonation, resale value and that adjustable rest, and its weakness at a price higher than the other student models it covers. It rates the Jupiter JCL700NA as the cheaper alternative: easy to service and band-director approved, though with lower resale value and a tone it calls solid rather than refined.
Pros:
- ✅ ABS body shrugs off cold rooms and rough handling
- ✅ Adjustable thumb rest with a strap ring
- ✅ Holds resale value, per Violet Recording
Cons:
- ❌ Higher price than the other student models in that guide
- ❌ The stock 4C mouthpiece is basic, and serious students tend to replace it
See the current listing below.
2. Buffet Crampon E11 — the first step up to wood
Wood brings a warmer sound and a maintenance routine, and the Buffet Crampon E11 is where most players first meet both. Buffet’s North America page calls it the first wooden student clarinet, and dealer pages describe an African blackwood body, 17 keys and 6 rings, undercut tone holes and stainless-steel springs. The conservatory guide lists it among its intermediate examples, in that $1,000 to $2,000 bracket.
The care routine is real. Violet Recording calls the E11 a splurge for a true beginner and says the wood needs careful warming up and swabbing to avoid cracks. Hello Music Theory’s review praises the tone and responsiveness, notes that some players found pitch issues it suggests may reflect a learning curve, and says screws may need tightening more often than on other brands, which it calls minor.
Origin is a small puzzle. Buffet’s North America page ties the E11 to its German workshops in Markneukirchen, while a European dealer page describes a newer “E11 France” line as made in France. These look like different versions of one name, so the label on the exact instrument decides which you are getting. Compare the exact model number before buying, since listings also split between silver-plated and nickel-plated keywork and between B-flat and A instruments.
The practical fit is a student who already has a year or two of lessons and a band director or teacher pushing toward a wooden sound. For a first-year beginner the conservatory’s own advice points elsewhere.
Check current availability on Amazon.
3. Selmer 1430LP — a school-ready bass clarinet to low Eb
“Selmer bass clarinet” can mean two very different purchases. Henri Selmer Paris makes the Privilege, which one dealer lists at roughly $17,000 to $19,000 depending on whether it goes to low Eb or low C. The Selmer 1430LP is the Conn-Selmer student model, built in the USA.
Its maker page describes a one-piece Resonite ABS body with the low Eb key on the body tube, so no keys span a joint, plus nickel-silver keys, a cylindrical bore, a fixed thumb rest, leather pads, a hard rubber mouthpiece, a hand-hammered brass bell and a wood-shell case meant for heavy band-room use. A dealer page confirms the written range as low Eb.
The low Eb limit is a design choice, not a flaw, and it has defenders. A longtime bass clarinet specialist at Earspasm wrote in 2012 that he auditioned for a conservatory on an old plastic low Eb Vito, and Jazz Bari Sax says low Eb horns are lighter and easier to carry on a neck strap. The same Jazz Bari Sax piece warns that players on a low Eb horn will still meet written low D, Db and C, and must read them an octave higher.
An Earspasm post on student mouthpieces adds a caution about this class of instrument: low resistance makes low Eb basses easy to blow but causes serious intonation problems across registers, and that is why some makers add resistance back into their mouthpieces. Independent owner reports on this specific model are thin, so treat the maker’s spec sheet as the firmest ground.
Pros:
- ✅ One-piece body, no keys crossing joints
- ✅ Leather pads and a case built for school use
- ✅ Lower weight than low C instruments, per Jazz Bari Sax
Cons:
- ❌ Fixed thumb rest
- ❌ Stops at low Eb, so some parts need octave transposition
- ❌ Stock mouthpiece is hard rubber, and mouthpiece choice affects intonation
4. Yamaha YCL-622II — full range down to low C
A youth-orchestra player posted on r/bassclarinet asking how to cover the low C parts of Shostakovich’s Seventh Symphony on a low Eb horn with no budget for a rental. That is the situation where a Yamaha YCL-622II, or any low C bass clarinet, earns its price: the part literally does not exist on the shorter instrument.
Yamaha’s US page describes it as a professional bass clarinet with a rich, warm sound and individually shaped undercut tone holes, and Yamaha’s heritage page credits the low C mechanism to a patent. A dealer listing fills in the rest: 24 keys, 7 covered finger holes, a grenadilla body, silver-plated keys, white leather pads and a Yamaha 4C mouthpiece. That same dealer lists it around $12,000 to $13,000, though the page showed it sold out. Availability needs checking, because Yamaha’s Singapore page labels the model discontinued while the US page carries no such notice.
Dawkes, a UK dealer, compares the low C field and calls the Buffet Prestige, Buffet Tosca and Selmer Privilege the main contenders for low C and prices all three above £8,000, then lists the Yamaha and the Uebel Emperior as the other options. Opinion on Yamaha basses splits. The 2012 Earspasm post prefers Selmer and Buffet for sound and says Yamaha lacks it, while Jazz Bari Sax calls the brand sturdy and reliable. Both are one player’s view.
The weight trade-off is documented too. Jazz Bari Sax notes that the extra length and keys of low C matter to doublers already carrying a baritone, and Backun’s fingering guide calls the right thumb the biggest adjustment for people switching from low Eb. A commenter in a 2024 r/bassclarinet thread called Backun’s plastic-bodied Alpha low C a pro-level instrument at around $3,700, while the Earspasm post from 2012 dismissed student low C horns from Jupiter and Allora as poorly built. Take the older criticism as dated.
5. Vandoren B45 Bass Clarinet Mouthpiece — freer-blowing upgrade for school basses
Often the instrument is fine and the mouthpiece is the limit. A bass clarinet mouthpiece changes resistance, tone and intonation more than most players expect, and the Vandoren B45 Bass Clarinet Mouthpiece is one of the standard upgrades.
A specialist dealer page lists a 1.93 mm tip opening and a medium-long facing, calls it a close relative of the B44 with a larger tip, and says that makes it more responsive across the register. A reviewer on Earspasm’s product page found the B45 a bit more free-blowing than the BD5, and described both as giving a warm, dark, full sound from low C into the altissimo. That is one buyer’s report, on a seller’s page.
For a beginner, Jazz Bari Sax’s author, who works for Vandoren and so has a stake, calls the BD5 very closed, dark and easy to play, describes the B45 as more responsive thanks to thinner rails, and puts the B50 at the open end. He suggests softer reeds than on a Bb clarinet, with strength 2 or 2½ as a start. The Earspasm BD5 page adds that the BD5 asks for harder reeds than the B40, and its reviewer suggests starting at a Vandoren V12 number 3.
The dealer lists it around $190 to $200, and no ligature or cap appears in that listing.
Clarinet reviews, read critically: what the roundups leave out
Ranked roundups disagree because they weigh different things. Hello Music Theory’s intermediate list puts a Buffet first and flags case problems on the Yamaha YCL450, whose semi-hard case it describes as basically a backpack and which it says humidifies poorly. Violet Recording lists pros and cons per model, with durability and resale in view. Neither tests the instruments side by side, so a ranking position is an opinion, not a measurement.
Three habits help. Check the date: the Earspasm bass clarinet posts are from 2012 and describe a market that has since added student low C models. Check the seller: a dealer’s product page is a sales page. And check for a second source: a claim repeated by the conservatory guide and by a forum is sturdier than one reviewer’s opinion.
Four ways a clarinet purchase goes sideways
A cheap overseas horn with no parts supply. The conservatory guide warns that some repair technicians refuse instruments with soft keywork because repairs drift out of alignment, and that replacement parts for budget brands are hard to find. It also tells buyers to insist that leaks and mechanical issues be fixed before purchase.
Low Eb now, low C needed later. Backun’s low C fingering guide shows how many keys and fingerings a low C instrument adds, and an r/bassclarinet commenter in a 2024 thread advised saving for low C if the player expects to stay with the instrument long-term, while another suggested cheaper low Eb models from Kessler or Ridenour. Both can be right for different players.
Trusting the stock mouthpiece. Hello Music Theory, Violet Recording and Earspasm all point toward replacing student mouthpieces. It is a smaller expense than a new instrument.
Ignoring the climate. Wood cracks in dry or cold conditions, according to the conservatory guide. A used instrument deserves a close look, too: the guide lists grime on the body, tone holes clogged with dried cork grease and pin marks from repaired cracks as red flags, with repaired cracks a reason for a lower price rather than automatic rejection.
Clarinet buying questions: beginner model, wood or plastic, low C, mouthpiece, rental
❓ What is the best clarinet for a beginner?
❓ Is a wooden clarinet better than a plastic one?
❓ What is the difference between a low C and a low Eb bass clarinet?
❓ Which bass clarinet mouthpiece should I start with?
❓ Should I rent or buy a first clarinet?
Choosing a clarinet in 2027: a short decision rule
Match the instrument to where you will play it next year, not to where you hope to be in ten. A first-year band student is well served by the Yamaha YCL-255; a player with a couple of years behind them and a teacher pushing for wood should look at the Buffet Crampon E11. Bass players divide by repertoire: the Selmer 1430LP covers school band down to low Eb, while the Yamaha YCL-622II is for parts that reach low C, and a Vandoren B45 Bass Clarinet Mouthpiece is the first upgrade worth considering on either bass.
If you only remember one rule from the sources, make it this: confirm that a technician can service the instrument before you fall for a price. A clarinet that cannot be repaired is cheap only until its first leak.
See which of these fits your budget on Amazon today.
Recommended for You
- Acoustic guitar capos — Which Clamp Suits Which Player
- Classical guitars: Which Neck Suits Your Hands?
- Advanced bass amplifier: Which One Fits Your Rig?
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through these links, at no additional cost to you.
Whichever horn you choose, a fresh reed and ten minutes of long tones will tell you more than any spec sheet.





